Unchaahi: against Female Foeticide in India

Friday, January 9, 2009

Why women hate women

Posted by Speaking Silence

I could never fathom the whole concept of women hating women in India. Why do mothers kill girl-child in their womb,why married women outcast widow, why mother-in-laws burn brides, why mothers love boy-child more than girls , why do they feed boys more than girls as happen in many communities? Why do women hate each other?

How can we change, how will people change and how will the world change when women never support women. We are weak because we are alone. We have no support not even from our own sex. Why is it so ?

Sex-selective abortion are not always forced upon by husbands and in-laws , they are often done in consensus by the mother. I have seen it so many times, in my own house, in my neighbours house. I have seen it first-hand and heard it from many friends. Maybe that's the way world rules and suppress us by turning us against each other. And we all are so well-trained in it. Have you every been to a village in India? I have been to one. Village of my parents. We went there every year for 3 months and I have seen abuse and humiliation. I have heard tales of horror and tales of abortions. Women discussing how to have a male-child,women discussing how to abort if its a girl-child, women getting abortions after ultrasound. I have seen it first-hand. I don't need to see any documentary for this stark reality. I feel it in my veins. I experienced it from my own mother. Because she desired a male-child and unfortunately God never bestowed this pleasure to her. She bore three girl and I am the second one. We grew up with a huge hole , a big dark vacuum in our house. Absence of a male-child. Not that I was beaten up or starved or not given education. I was given all that just like every child in Delhi, good food and good education. But I knew the existence of this sorrow deep within my parents . I knew the stabbing pain that they harbored. I resented it but never held any grudges against them until my own child was born. A girl child. I felt that same sorrow and anger oozing out of my mother against her . She almost cursed God but I will not let this happen to my daughter.I will never let her feel that gush that my mother sends to me. I will protect her till my last breath and I will teach my child to love women. I will teach her to uphold her pride. I will teach her to stand tall as a woman .

How can a mother , a grandmother do such a thing. I feel at loss at all of this, at my mother , my community, my relative, my village and my country. What should I tell my daughter about India? That it is a land where girls are killed for being a girl. That women are raped in day-light , that girls are teased in crowd. That women hate each other so much. I feel at loss . I feel sad and angry. I feel betrayed.

Labels: , , ,

18 Comments:

  • And yesterday I received a comment FROM A WOMAN (?) BLOGGER, on a simple post against gender stereotypes, that said (amongst a lot of other things)
    Recently Shiv Raj Singh Chauhan donated Rs2 lakh for every family in which the first kid borne was a girl in the year 2008.

    Whose money he was wasting? The Tax payers money. Then he donated a cycle for every college going girl. Whose money he was wasting?

    Its common thing in general.

    The feminists who seeks government's help (by any means) be it reservation or women rights or special laws etc are no better than the male chauvinists who oppressed women in some or other way under there collectivist approaches. No similar collectivist approaches these feminists apply for themselves.

    its distortion of freedom and liberty nothing else.

    Law should be similar to all.

    About the attrocities done to women in past,

    Evil requires sanction of victim


    There was gargi, there was durga, there was lakshmi bai there was sarojini naidu there was the most attrocious woman of modern India the tyrant dictator Indira Gandhi.

    And if feminists won't leave their collective approach, they will cause havoc in India too just like they did in UK.

    Feminism is not wrong if it is Individual's stride to live for her natural rights, her natural freedom. Let it be individual feminism. let every woman have same legal rights as any man do have. otherwise it is unjust!


    So obviously these little unborn baby girls with eye lashes and nails just developing have only got themselves to blame :(

    By Blogger Indian Home Maker, At January 9, 2009 at 9:35 PM  

  • I forgot to put inverted commas, the part in italics are quoted from the comment.

    By Blogger Indian Home Maker, At January 9, 2009 at 9:38 PM  

  • My mother has three sisters, and no brother. At times I feel my grandmother feels that maybe if she had a son, in her now old age, she might have had a person who she can depend on. Now the four sisters are at four corners of the worlds and each of them can take out only a set amount of time.

    I think a girl child is always seen as 'to go' and hence a male child is seen a support all through life. Hence maybe they also try to offer and appease the male child more.

    By Blogger Aathira, At January 10, 2009 at 1:01 AM  

  • They play o the patriarchy, trying to make life easier for themselves- in the truth setting everyone back a million years. Its not the overt displays also the covert ones- the very "modern" woman who says "yes" to everything her husband says, no matte how stupid. Including those who now talk of "equal rights" as if everyone is on an equal level playing field. They try to be as simplistic as possible, even while trying to pretend everything is alright.

    By Blogger @lankr1ta, At January 10, 2009 at 10:32 AM  

  • Well said Alankrita, I agree. Also I read elsewhere, a male commenter claiming this is actually a battle of the sexes. I think it is a social problem. And we have our religion, tradition and culture to blame.

    By Blogger Indian Home Maker, At January 10, 2009 at 10:38 AM  

  • So true, Women are definitely women's own enemies.. I have heard of so many instances of people justifying the killing of an unborn child, just because its a girl! When we got to know that we were expecting a girl, both of us were delirious with joy - but my husband's brother asked him 'Tum Kush to ho na bhaiya?' Would this question have ever come if it had been a boy??? And the sad thing is that we don't even need to go to villages to see such things- it happens everywhere.. Its fine for the first child to be a girl - but second time - oh no! We need so many more voices like these, to combat the damage that society has dealt to the women of our country!

    By Blogger Smitha, At January 11, 2009 at 11:01 AM  

  • Wow- that is a really amazing and tragic story. But you are going to break that cycle aren't you- that is half the reason for writing this post, I'm imagining?
    I just finished my thesis at university dealing with this exact issue and am about to start on it all over again for my PhD (women in India perpetuating this practice of violence against other women).
    Unfortunately it is so much more complex that 'women hating women'. There are processes in which women internalise patriarchal norms through familial and socialisation process (boys are often preferenced in terms of education and medical care, girls are consistently seen as vulnerable), son-less mothers are often pitied by society, and they lack old age security hence the reliance on sons. And of course, there's Moksha.
    The fact is - and this is strongly supported by the research - these days it is the more typically empowered women (educated, literate, comparatively wealthy) women who are overwhelmingly contributing to the declining sex ratio (for various reasons).
    Women AND men must both work towards emancipation together- after all, the genders don't exist in some sort of social vaccuum.

    By Blogger Nina, At January 15, 2009 at 12:03 AM  

  • Nina,you said it right, its more complex than just women hating women. Its the way our society has altered itself, its the way thoughts, minds and opinions have been changed forever. There are many reasons for it but the saddest part is that women , like me, who dont believe in this are emotionally black-mailed by our society, parents to wish for a son. We are very family-based society and parents are still obeyed and looked up for advice. When our in-laws, parents and society start to persuade us we feel helpless and confused. Its my story and its story of every home in India and every Indian home in US.

    By Blogger SpeakingSilence, At January 16, 2009 at 9:44 AM  

  • Yes- the family unit is such a powerful force in India, isn't it?? I think you are amazing for being so open and articulate about this issue and how it has affected your life. And I look forward to reading more of your posts!

    By Blogger Nina, At January 17, 2009 at 1:07 AM  

  • Hi,
    I felt goosebumps as I read your post. You've seen too much, and I want to ask you so many questions. You've seen sex-selection of foetuses first-hand. Do these people feel any kind of guilt or remorse while aborting a girl child? What is the primary reason you think people in our society yearn for a male child? Is it status, old-age support, fear of dowry or all these factors?

    As the very very proud mom of a girl child myself, i am so happy that you have chosen to love and cherish your child, and teach her to support and respect women.

    I know I will be there for my parents when they are older, even though I am married and have other responsibilities. My parents are also my responsibility. I am sure my daughter too will learn that aged parents need not necessarily depend only on a male child.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At January 17, 2009 at 2:13 AM  

  • Hi Nina,

    It's great to know that you are pursuing a PhD (women in India perpetuating this practice of violence against other women)on the subject. Please do share your knowledge with us. Also where are you based?

    By Blogger sc, At January 17, 2009 at 2:18 AM  

  • Oh my! Good you vented it all out and thats the spirit! I hope your daughter is blessed with all the success in life:)

    By Blogger Mithe, At January 17, 2009 at 4:53 AM  

  • Lol, you are so frustrated. Please read Steven Goldberg's "The Inevitability of Patriarchy" and "Why Men Rule?"

    I'm not sure if they are available in Indian book markets though!

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At January 24, 2009 at 11:47 PM  

  • Hiya SC :-)
    Hope all is well with you!
    I am based in Brisbane, Australia (where I was born and bred) but my husband is Indian (hence the fascination for the topic) and we go back to Mumbai once a year to visit his family.
    In fact, we are going back on Sunday for a month and I can't wait!
    I'm going to be meeting up with a men's organisation, Men Against Violence Against Women (MAVA) who see rather amazing. I keep being drawn back to the idea that although women's 'empowerment' and 'emancipation' is important in overcoming patriarchal constraints, men MUST also be liberated from the same, and must be incorporated into solutions to the son preference cultures.
    Oops- sorry for babbling :-) Had a meeting with my PhD supervisors today and just keep thinking this is something which needs to be incorporated into policy approaches (particularly since the current strategies are FAR from effective)...
    So what about you, SC?? Where are you in this wonderful world?!
    Take care,
    Nina

    By Blogger Nina, At January 28, 2009 at 6:56 AM  

  • To the 'anon' person who made the post regarding Steven Goldberg's books:
    Surely you are making a joke, particularly on this site...?

    By Blogger Nina, At January 28, 2009 at 7:01 AM  

  • Well.. lets see I will try to answer 'anon' questions here .

    Do these people feel any kind of guilt or remorse while aborting a girl child? --- Women that I have seen and met don't. Its strange and so scary that these women come home and resume their household duties after killing a baby in their wombs. This is exactly what is called brainwashing.


    What is the primary reason you think people in our society yearn for a male child? Is it status, old-age support, fear of dowry or all these factors?-----

    To be frank. I dont know . It IS status in today's world. If you have a son , somehow women feel confident and ... empowered... strong??!!! I cannot tell why .

    It WAS old-age support in olden days but this has changed so much . Nobody stays with their parents anymore.
    Fear of Dowry. You BET YA! And maybe many-many more

    Infact, just recently I was talking to my mom who was telling me how old people are thrown out of thier own houses by their son and daughter-in-laws. I was surprised that even these facts doesnot changes attitude of people. They keep listening and viewing such realities and accept it as inevitable. Parents are ready to be ill-treated by their sons and daughter-in-laws (sometimes) , thrown out of their homes, stripped away from their money, properties BUT still they will keep praying and yearning for sons.

    By Blogger SpeakingSilence, At January 30, 2009 at 9:46 AM  

  • Good site.... good article...
    Work from home

    By Blogger raj, At August 4, 2009 at 3:13 PM  

  • Message………………………
    We need your help to spread this empowering message to women and all citizens around. There are millions of women from all over the world who need encouragement and the truth that they are worthy and remarkable. One small act of kindness on your part can cause a ripple that reaches thousands of women everywhere.

    Kartar Aasra Old age Orphanage Home
    Your mother was someone’s daughter
    Still want to send your girl to slaughter?
    Give the girl child an opportunity to make her parents proud.
    Don’t kill her
    Join hands, turn the tide
    Say ‘NO’ to female infanticide.
    Drop them at our newly installed Cradle (Pungura) at Kartar Aasra Entrance.
    http://www.kartaraasra.org/ +91 9878888838

    By Blogger Kartar Aasra Trust, At January 14, 2012 at 11:13 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]



Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home